What Is BDS/ The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions against Israel?

Image result for images of rep ILHAN OMAR , RASHIDA TLAIB
US REPS. RASHIDA TLAIB/ ILHAN OMAR

Fortunately Nathan Thrall of the Guardian has penned an 8/14/2018 credible, objective analysis of “BDS/ the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions against Israel, where the support of this boycott is defined by Israeli law to be a threat to the existence of Israel, as a Jewish State, sufficient enough to provide Israeli officials with justification to comply with the republican President Donald Trump’s request to bar two of his Democratic Party Muslim bogeymen, US Congressional Representatives Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, entry into Israel.

It’s my opinion that an objective look at the BDS movement has to viewed from an historical perspective. There’s a reason that the Palestinian region is occupied. That perspective as in a past feuds, as what happened in Northern Ireland, gets lost overtime. The reality is that the continuation of the status quo is a prescription for gridlock to where the long held hope of a two state solution for both Israel and Palestine, where officials acknowledge the right to for both communities to exist in a tolerant and peaceful environment, becomes “Mission Impossible.”

Image result for images of rep ILHAN OMAR , RASHIDA TLAIB

Here’s the rest of the story…

This controversial decision by Israel has raised interest in what BDS is, and Mr. Thrall tackles this issue, in his op-ed piece, “BDS: How a controversial non-violent movement has transformed the Israeli-Palestinian debate:” (“Israel sees the international boycott campaign as an existential threat to the Jewish state. Palestinians regard it as their last resort.”)

Excerpts:

“The movement for Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions against Israel – known as BDS – has been driving the world a little bit mad. Since its founding 13 years ago, it has acquired nearly as many enemies as the Israelis and Palestinians combined. It has hindered the efforts of Arab states to fully break their own decades-old boycott in pursuit of increasingly overt cooperation with Israel. It has shamed the Palestinian Authority government in Ramallah by denouncing its security and economic collaboration with Israel’s army and military administration. It has annoyed the Palestine Liberation Organization by encroaching on its position as the internationally recognised advocate and representative of Palestinians worldwide.”

Image result for images of rep ILHAN OMAR , RASHIDA TLAIB

“It has infuriated the Israeli government by trying to turn it into a leper among liberals and progressives. It has exasperated what is left of the Israeli peace camp by nudging the Palestinians away from an anti-occupation struggle and towards an anti-apartheid one. It has induced such an anti-democratic counter-campaign by the Israeli government that it has made Israeli liberals fear for the future of their country. And it has caused major headaches for the Palestinians’ donor governments in Europe, which are pressured by Israel not to work with BDS-supporting organisations in the Palestinian territories, an impossible request given that nearly all major civil society groups in Gaza and the West Bank support the movement.”

Image result for images of rep ILHAN OMAR , RASHIDA TLAIB

“In an era of corporate social responsibility, BDS has given bad publicity to major businesses tied up in Israel’s occupation (AirbnbRe/MaxHP) and helped push other large firms out of the West Bank. It has disrupted film festivals, concerts and exhibitions around the world. It has riled academic and sports organisations by politicising them, demanding that they take a stand on the highly divisive conflict. It has angered Palestinian performers and artists who work with Israeli institutions, accusing them of giving Palestinian cover for Israel’s human rights violations.”

“In the UK, BDS has brought turmoil to courts and local councils, embroiling them in disputes over the legality of local boycotts of settlement goods. In the US, BDS has caused two dozen states to pass bills or issue orders inhibiting or penalising those boycotting Israel or its settlements, pitting Israel’s allies against free speech advocates such as the American Civil Liberties Union. It has ignited debates in Protestant churches in the US, some of the largest of which have divested from companies that profit from Israel’s occupation. It has become the bane of college administrators, forced to adjudicate complaints from BDS-supporting professors and students that their free speech has been stifled, and claims by Zionist faculty, donors and undergraduates that their campuses have become “unsafe” spaces. It has pulled liberals toward greater support for the Palestinians, making Israel an increasingly partisan issue in the US, associated less with Democrats and progressives than with Trump, evangelicals and the far right.”

Image result for images of rep ILHAN OMAR , RASHIDA TLAIB

“In the Jewish diaspora, BDS has created new schisms on the centre-left, which has been forced into a vice by the rightwing and pro-settlement Israeli government on one hand, and the non-Zionist left on the other. It has prompted liberal Zionists to grapple with why they sometimes accept the boycott of products from settlements but not the boycott of the state that creates and sustains them. It has compelled Israel’s more critical supporters to justify their opposition to non-violent forms of pressure on Israel, when the absence of real pressure has done nothing to bring occupation or settlement expansion to an end. It has put the onus on liberal Zionists to defend their support not for the abstract ideal of what they hope Israel might one day become, but for the actual, longstanding practices of the state, including expropriations of Palestinian land for Jewish settlement; detention of hundreds of Palestinians without trial or charge; collective punishment of 2 million Gazans living under a more than decade-long blockade; and institutionalised inequality between Jewish and Palestinian citizens of Israel. BDS has deprived Israel’s liberal supporters of the excuse that an aberrant occupation or rightwing governments are mainly to blame for the state’s undemocratic practices.”

Link: Click here:  “BDS:How A Controversial Non-Violent Movement The Israeli -Plaestinain Debate”

BDS: how a controversial non-violent movement has transformed the Israeli-Palestinian debate –

See: youtube.com/ Bill Maher on BDS…

3 comments

  1. Hello Gronda. I support the BDS movement as the situation between the Palestinians and the Israelis is a crime against humanity. These things the Israeli government is doing now to the Palestinians are the very things done to the Jews in the 1930’s. I am reminded of the effort to end apartheid in South Africa and the role BDS played in ending that. As for Bill Maher I have heard him on his show talk about it. He has moved to the right over the years and is now so scared of tRump that he has moved from the progressive he use to be to a corporate democrat not willing to support anything a moderate Republican wouldn’t like. His stance on the Palestine / Israel conflict is for the Palestinians to get over it, to let the state of Israel do what it wishes, and for the world to look the other way. All because he is afraid tRump / Republicans will claim Democrats hate Israel. Well they are going to say that anyway and it is just another lie. Face the liars and defeat the lie not by embracing the the liar’s side but by exposing the real problems. I find Maher’s shilling for Biden at all costs because he thinks he can beat tRump to be short sighted. No one knows what / who is electable until the voting is done. It is all speculation. I speculate people want real change. That is what got tRump the presidency. People seen him as change and Hillary as more of the same that was not working for them. So why repeat that? People want change on the Palestine / Israel conflict also and they dislike the bullies. Hugs

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Gronda, what is important is the US/ Israel relationship is bigger than its two boastful people in leadership roles. To politicize this relationship for short term gain is unfortunate. Our allies are imperfect just as we are. We should take it to heart when our allies tell us they disagree with us. The six partners in the Iran Nuclear deal said to the US don’t pull out, with our generals agreeing. But we did and look at what is happening now. Keith

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I am neutral on Israel. However, my concern with BDS is that I may be slightly confrontational in tone.

    The U.S. dug itself into a giant hole pertaining to its relationship to Israel.
    If they say jump, we tend to say how high. We never say no. As a noninterventionist do not like that dynamic of the alliance.

    However, both Palestine and Israel have done s***ty things to one another. Both have blood on their hands. Both have been in the wrong.

    https://invertedlogicblog.wordpress.com/2019/08/30/polemics33-the-israel-effect-we-may-bend-to-israels-will-as-they-embark-upon-a-campaign-of-aggression-on-iran/

    Like

Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.