GOP EX-President’s change of US policy towards Israel’s stance on West Bank needs fixing

CARTOON: Trump and Netanyahu's two-state solution

I’ve been painting the right-wing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as a clone of the US GOP MAGA ex-president, a man who aligns himself with extreme right colleagues and who’d do just about anything to maintain his tenuous hold to power.

Does this sound familiar? PM Netanyahu has been doing his best to overhaul Israeli’s legal infrastructure so that it’ll be almost impossible to oust him from office even if he’ll be found guilty of corruption, fraud, etc. within the next couple of months. (I’ll be writing more about this in a future blog.)

President Trump at the Israel Museum. Jerusalem May 23, 20… | Flickr
Ex-president TRUMP/ PM NETANYAHU

Yes, the US GOP ex-president did everything within his power to help out his Israeli buddy, PM Netanyahu, including supporting Israel’s illegal encroachment of Israeli settlers in the West Bank. In the past, the US/ International policy declared that any Israeli settlements in the West Bank beyond the 1949 armistice lines were illegal.

Emboldened by this change in US policy, it’s almost impossible to paint how horrifically Palestinians have been treated by Israelis in the West Bank.

The democratic party US POTUS Joe Biden has yet to reverse the above Trump policy which was implemented just about one month prior to the 2020 US presidential elections, and I want to know why that is?

Background:

As per the February 27, 2018 Washington Post article, Israel’s justice minister explains why Trump is good for her West …by Ruth Eglash, the Trump’s administration willingness to turn a blind eye to some of Israel’s actions that had been decried by previous White Houses of both parties, set up for the conditions that we see in Israel today.

Excerpts:

“The Trump administration has, so far, been less critical of unilateral Israeli policies in the occupied territories compared to its predecessors, and politicians on Israel’s right have argued it is time to take advantage. Justice Minister Ayelet Shaked is one of them.”

“Shaked, 41, is second-in-command in the ardently Zionist, right-wing Jewish Home party, which draws the bulk of its support from the more than 400,000 Israeli settlers living in the West Bank.”

“She is an outspoken advocate of annexing parts of the West Bank territory that Palestinians hope to obtain for a future state. Just this week, a government committee she heads approved a bill that aims to extend the jurisdiction of Israel’s district courts over a portion of the West Bank she wants Israel to annex.”

“If this legislation becomes law, it would prevent Palestinians from petitioning Israel’s High Court over land disputes with the settlements, a development Palestinians fear will weaken their cause and strengthen Israel’s control of the land.”

CARTOON: Trump and Netanyahu’s real peace plan

Q: If you are not talking about a Palestinian state, aren’t you talking about a continued occupation?

A: No. I’m talking about a confederation, that Area A, B and Gaza become part of Jordan, which is majority Palestinian anyway.

You know that in the 1980s, [Israeli peace activist] Abie Nathan was jailed because he met with [the late Palestine Liberation Organization chairman Yasser] Arafat. It was illegal then to speak to Arafat. No one was talking about a two-state solution until the ’90s, then it became an acceptable solution.

Trump’s ‘deal of the century’ won’t bring peace – that was the plan ...

“Today, Israeli sovereignty in Area C and a confederation in area A and B with Jordan looks like a bizarre option to the international community, but this is something we will continue to talk about and explain.”

“I believe that in three years from now, the international community will understand this is the right solution.”

Q: Does this idea look even more possible now that President Trump is in the White House?

A: “Of course. With the Obama administration, this issue was more difficult. The White House is [now] more open, and I think Trump is a very brave president. He thinks outside the box and is not tied to the State Department’s old paradigms.”

So, just one month before the 2020 US presidential election, the GOP MAGA ex-president Trump reversed a long-standing US policy based on a 1978 1978 memo by State Department legal adviser Herbert Hansell, which deemed Israeli settlements beyond the 1949 armistice lines as illegal. This reversal was formulated by the Kohelet Policy Forum – the right-wing Israeli think tank behind Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s controversial judicial overhaul efforts.

Ben Samuels author of the June, 27, 2023 Haaretz article, “Biden Isn’t Reversing Trump’s Major Settlement Move – Yet writes about how Trump instituted the so-called ‘Pompeo Doctrine,’ a policy shift from one in place in 1978, that deemed Israel’s settlements now legal in the West Bank. He writes that POTUS Biden’s decision to cut funds to institutions in the territories within the West Bank hints at a change in policy, but it does not mean Washington is going back to pre-Trump days.

Excerpts:

White House has not overturned the Trump administration’s policy that the United States no longer views Israel’s settlements as illegal.

“We have not taken that step,” confirmed State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller, when asked if the Biden administration was reversing the key tenet of then-President Donald Trump’s settlement policy.”

  • “Informally known as the “Pompeo Doctrine,” the policy rested on the belief that settlements were “not per se inconsistent with international law.” This overturned a 1978 memo by State Department legal adviser Herbert Hansell, which deemed Israeli settlements beyond the 1949 armistice lines as illegal.”

See: The daily, grinding violence in the West Bank is worse than ever/ Guardian

Israeli settlers drive anti-Palestinian violence in the West Bank/ NBC

In the West Bank, Israeli settlers are on an anti-Palestinian rampage/ VOX

Palestinians are shaken by deadly attacks in the West Bank : NPR