aside Betsy Devos Failed Charter School Experiment In Michigan

Image result for photos of betsy devos

There were many of the republican President Donald Trump’s nominees who should not have been confirmed by the republicans in the US Senate, and number one on that list is Betsy Devos as Secretary for the Department of Education. She is a darling of the far-right for her single minded determination to promote Charter Schools in Michigan. Her efforts have been proven to be a failure as detailed in the below lengthy report. The link to the entire report is footnoted at the end of this post.


Here’s the rest of the story….

On September 5, 2017, Mark Binelli of the New York Times Magazine penned the following report. “Michigan Gambledon Charter Schools. Its Children Lost.”


“Toss a dart at a map of Detroit, and the bull’s-eye, more or less, would be a tiny city called Highland Park. Only three square miles, Highland Park is surrounded by Detroit on nearly all sides, but it remains its own sovereign municipality thanks largely to Henry Ford, who started building Model Ts there in 1910. Ford didn’t care for the idea of paying Detroit taxes, so he pressured Highland Park to resist annexation by the larger city. By the end of the decade, his Albert Kahn-designed factory had revolutionized mass production. Five years later, Walter Chrysler started his own car company a few blocks away. “

The George Washington Carver Academy in Highland Park, Mich. Credit Jonno Rattman for The NY Times

“Sylvia Brown lives in the suburbs now, but she still proudly calls herself a Parker, the local term for a Highland Park native. When Brown was a kid, she’d tell people she lived in the capital of Detroit. Her father worked for the city, and her mother taught at the public elementary school. In high school, Brown played on the volleyball and tennis teams and won a scholarship her junior year to study abroad in Japan.”

“So when the offer came last summer to take a job as the superintendent of George Washington Carver Academy, a pre-K-8 charter school in Highland Park, Brown thrilled at the chance to come home. She also had no illusions about what she was signing up for. In 1992, Brown’s sophomore year at Highland Park High, Chrysler’s corporate headquarters decamped to exurban Auburn Hills, a departure that cost Highland Park a quarter of its tax base and 50 percent of its annual budget. Today the city is staring down the same problems as much of Detroit: crime, abandonment, disinvestment.”

Voyageur Academy in Detroit. Credit Jonno Rattman for The New York Times

“A major victim of the city’s borderline insolvency was its public-school system, which had been under state control since 2012. (Six different state-appointed emergency managers have run the district since then.) Plummeting enrollment, legacy costs and financial mismanagement had left the school system with a projected deficit of $10 million. The state’s solution that year was to “charterize” the entire district: void the teacher’s union contract, fire all employees and turn over control of the schools to a private, for-profit charter operator. But enrollment at Highland Park High continued to decline, so the state closed the school in 2015. Highland Park now has no high school, either public or charter. Families send their children to high schools in Detroit or the suburbs, where they have no electoral influence over local officials or school boards.”

Image result for cartoon on betsy devos

“Even setting aside standardized test scores, which are debatable as measures of “success” or “failure,” Carver probably isn’t the sort of institution where most school-choice proponents would send their own children. In past years, headlines involving Carver included a 2008 cheating scandal (in which teachers were caught improperly coaching fourth and fifth graders on the answers to standardized tests) and a 2011 felony embezzlement conviction (of the school’s treasurer, who used $25,000 earmarked for textbooks to buy herself a house). Today, the school still lacks needed funds.”

It looks like she is buying this position“Charter proponents will point out, correctly, that you could work up a similar indictment of any number of public schools in struggling cities like Detroit. But in theory, at least, public-school districts have superintendents tasked with evaluating teachers and facilities. Carver, on the other hand, is accountable to more ambiguous entities — like, for example, Oak Ridge Financial, the Minnesota-based financial-services firm that sent a team of former educators to visit the school. They had come not in service of the children but on behalf of shareholders expecting a thorough vetting of a long-term investment: Brown was in negotiations with Oak Ridge about refinancing the school’s debt in order to make much-needed repairs, and the firm was performing the sort of oversight normally handled by a school district. Michigan schools remaining in the bottom fifth percentile for three years running must close, which, in the case of Carver, would leave Oak Ridge on the hook for a 13-year loan.”

Image result for cartoon on betsy devos

“The crisis at Carver Academy was not unfolding in isolation. Michigan’s aggressively free-market approach to schools has resulted in one of the most deregulated educational environments in the country, a laboratory in which consumer choice and a shifting landscape of supply and demand (and profit motive, in the case of many charters) were pitched as ways to improve life in the classroom for the state’s 1.5 million public-school students. But a Brookings Institution analysis done this year of national test scores ranked Michigan last among all states when it came to improvements in student proficiency. And a 2016 analysis by the Education Trust-Midwest, a nonpartisan education policy and research organization, found that 70 percent of Michigan charters were in the bottom half of the state’s rankings. Michigan has the most for-profit charter schools in the country and some of the least state oversight. Even staunch charter advocates have blanched at the Michigan model.”

Related ArticleMichigan Gambled on Charter Schools. Its Children Lost. – . 9/5/17


    • Dear David Prosser,

      This has been the republican party’s dream for years which is another failed vision, right up there with “trickle down” economics.

      Hugs, Gronda


  1. Betsy DeVos … first of all, she has no idea of what struggles lower and middle income families have just to manage to send their kids to school, for little Betsy was born with a silver spoon in her mouth. Second, her plan, if allowed to come to fruition, is unconstitutional, as it uses tax dollars that should go to public schools for ALL children and gives them to religious organizations. Anybody ever hear of separation of church & state? And lastly, charter schools, even if done right, provide an education or an opportunity, if you will, for a few … a very few, relatively speaking. That leaves the majority of children still attending public schools that are now way underfunded because their funds have been given to the charter schools. So you are left with the majority of the children in schools that may be unsafe for they couldn’t afford much-needed repairs, used or obsolete text books, underpaid and too few teachers. What is wrong with this picture? Well, for one thing, where will we find intelligent, well-educated leaders in future generations? Sigh.


    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear Jill,

      I would like to say that she was at least, well intended, but I can’t. When she set up these schools, she did not allow for any over-sight procedures. She even blocked the state of MI from implementing by law, any oversight procedures.

      Was the real plan to break the teachers’ union?

      I wish there was a way for the children to file a class action suit against her, personally.

      Hugs, Gronda

      Liked by 1 person

      • Yes, it was an ill-conceived plan and she had no good intentions. She is just another of DDT’s rich cronies hoping to increase their wealth and power at the expense of We The People and our children. Sacrifice the 90% for the 10% … sound familiar? Hugs!!!


  2. Dear Suzanne,

    Betsy DeVos does not appear to be a very warm type person. She should not be allowed to be anywhere near school children, as she has done them, real harm.

    Hugs, Gronda


Comments are closed.