aside Boston Slashed Its Crime Rate By Treating Peoples Even In M13 Gangs As Humans, Not Animals

Image result for photos of boston m13 gangs police

How is it that a major city like Boston was able to cut its crime rate by 79% by treating even those in gangs, as humans, instead of as animals, as described by the republican President Donald Trump?

As per a 2/22/18 Boston Globe op-ed piece, “Most of what Americans know about MS-13 comes from an unreliable source: President Trump. The violent transnational street gang has been a centerpiece of Trump’s fiery anti-immigrant rhetoric, raising the group’s profile without offering much by way of fact-based analysis.”

Image result for MS-13: Separating truth from fiction

“MS-13 has “literally taken over towns and cities of the US,” the president said last year. ”

“MS-13 is a real threat, but Trump’s rhetoric on the subject, intermingled with his customary racist hyperbole, only makes it harder for the public and local authorities to understand the gang and fashion strategies to combat it. The public deserves a full-scale assessment, perhaps in the form of a Congressional investigation, of the transnational gang’s criminality and the threat it poses, and the right policies to fight it successfully.”

See: MS-13: Separating truth from fiction – Boston Globe

Here is the rest of the story…

On May 18, 2018, German Lopez of VOX penned the following report, “Trump’s dangerous “animals” rhetoric is also bad crime-fighting policy” (” Boston slashed violent crime by 79 percent — by treating people who committed crimes as, well, people.”)

Image result for photos of boston m13 gangs police

“Earlier this week, President Donald Trump said that some undocumented immigrants deported from the US aren’t people. These are animals.” The remarks quickly drew criticism — widely interpreted as Trump once again characterizing Latinx immigrants as subhuman rapists and criminals. Trump, in clarifying his remarks, later said that he was speaking solely about MS-13 gang members and that he “always will” refer to those in MS-13 as animals.”

“So that’s that, right? After all, who’s going to stand up for MS-13 members who are attacking and killing people across the US and Latin America? As Daily Beast reporter Lachlan Markay tweeted, “‘Actually, MS-13 gangbangers are still human beings’ is not the hill to die on.”

Image result for photos of boston m13 gangs police

“But there’s a compelling reason to treat these people as humans, not animals or monsters. It’s not just the moral concept that everyone deserves to be treated as a human being. Treating people who commit crimes as human beings — with compassion, understanding, and empathy — is part of what you need to do to convince them to change and persuade others in similar situations to not follow the same path to a life of gangs and crime.”

“That’s not just a theory. It’s demonstrated by some of the most effective policing strategies out there.”

“When Boston was dealing with its own major gang and violence problem in the 1990s, it deployed a response that was built largely on the idea of treating the people committing these crimes as humans. That helped produce the “Boston Miracle,” in which violent crime dropped by an astonishing 79 percent throughout the decade.”

“If America really wants to stop MS-13, Boston’s approach is one proven model to replicate.”

 

Image result for photos of boston m13 gangs police

To stop MS-13, understand why people join the group

“People don’t become MS-13 gangbangers because they have hearts full of darkness. They do it because they face a series of incentives to do so: Perhaps in a community in which they face constant discrimination and isolation because of their immigration status or country of origin, MS-13 is one group that offers them a sense of belonging. Maybe for kids who feel lonely and unsure about their future, the group offers a sense of meaning. Or in countries with virtually no strong institutions, MS-13 can fill the gaps by giving some sense of structure.”

“Consider this explanation for why someone would become a “homegirl” for MS-13, from Michael Miller and Justin Jouvenal at the Washington Post:”

“Becoming a homegirl once provided some protection, said Tom Ward, an anthropologist who spent much of the 1990s hanging out with MS-13 in Los Angeles, where the gang was founded, for his book, “Gangsters Without Borders.”

“There was an unwritten rule that you can’t rape a homegirl,” he said. “Homegirls weren’t running things, but some had a lot of respect.”

Related image

“In this context, joining MS-13 was a rational decision, a means of survival in a world that often won’t offer these girls any protection, because the government in El Salvador does not have the criminal justice institutions to do so or the government in the US just isn’t paying attention.”

This is not to excuse the horrific crimes that MS-13 members often go on to commit. But you have to understand why people join violent gangs if you want any chance at stopping it.

Related image

This level of understanding is at the heart of promising policing strategies

“At the core of Boston’s approach was a community policing strategy known as “focused deterrence.”

“Richard Rosenfeld, a criminologist at the University of Missouri in St. Louis, previously explained the two prongs of focused deterrence: “We clearly know who you are, where you live, and we’re going to do everything we can to stop the violence in this community — and if that means that we arrest and charge you with a serious violent crime, we’re going to do that. If you want out of this life, then, secondly, here are services and support that you might find useful to set a different direction of your life.”

“So, yes, part of the solution is telling people they’ll face consequences if they break the law and punishing them if they commit crimes. But crucially, the model also acknowledges that people don’t fall into gangs or violence for no reason and provides social services — jobs, housing, and so on — to fill at least some of the gaps that may drive someone to commit crimes or join a gang.”

Image result for PHOTOS OF Rev. Jeffrey Brown

“Rev. Jeffrey Brown, who was heavily involved in Boston’s use of focused deterrence, said in a TED talk that the second prong was crucial to the city’s success.”

“One of the biggest myths was that these kids were cold and heartless and un-characteristically bold in their violence,” he said. “What we found out was the exact opposite. Most of the young people who were out there in the streets are just trying to make it. And we also found out that some of the most intelligent and creative and magnificent and wise people we’ve ever met were on the street, engaged in a struggle.”

“The offer of social services also give legitimacy to the government and police: signaling that they’re there both to enforce the law and to try to help people out of their dire circumstances. With that trust, police are better equipped to work with the community and do their jobs, and perhaps would-be gang members realize that there are other options besides joining a gang to find a sense of purpose and protection.”

“That lends a certain legitimacy to the police,” Rosenfeld said. “They’re not there to just serve warrants or warn people about what’s going to happen to them if they commit another crime but also convey a certain degree of concern for those individuals and their lives.”

“This has worked beyond Boston. Study after study backs up the approach as a successful model to combat crime, not just related to gangs like MS-13 but with gun violence more broadly.”

“If I really wanted the community that I was preaching for, I needed to reach out and embrace this group that I had cut out of my definition,” Brown said. “Which meant [it’s] not about building programs to catch those who are in the fences of violence but to reach out and to embrace those who were committing the acts of violence — the gangbangers, the drug dealers.”

8 comments

  1. This is exactly what I have been saying for years, though I didn’t always have many people to say it to. How did I know to say that? Because I have been there, I have lived on the streets, and I know how I got off the streets. (This is simplifying things greatly, just skimming the tops of the process without getting deep into the subject, but there was no one to get deep for when no one was listening.) Nor am I trying to take any credit because I did not influence anyone that I know of, all I did was say in my small world what others were apparently already doing in other larger parts of the world. However, it does make me happy to know that other people successfilly tried treating everyone as people.
    Thank you, Gronda, for writing this post. Keep letting people know that being nice, empathic, and compassionate do work. They are our best weapons against hatred and violence.

    • Dear Rawgod,

      You are so right.

      The law enforcement segment would have much more success in fighting crime if they offered both the carrot and the stick. There will always be those who belong behind bars, but many could be saved if they were offered a legitimate alternative. But that happens when police learn to treat peoples with respect and dignity whenever possible. They have to see peoples as human beings instead of “no better than dirt., scum, thugs’

      It makes me sick when I see police act with unnecessary force when they didn’t even talk to the peoples involved or when they did nothing to deescalate a difficult situation.

      Boston is an example that other city police departments should follow instead of listening to leaders like President Trump.

      Thanks for sharing your perspective.

      Hugs, Gronda

      • Thanks, Gronda. But if it weren”t for you, I would have no place to make such comments. I have a very different philosophy on life from most people, and I don’t have many people to express it to that are willing to listen. But you and Jill give me lots of opportunities, and if you inspire me to say something, I usually say it. So thank you, too.

Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.