Frankly I expected better from a Marine Corp 4 star general. The republican President Trump’s Chief of Staff General John Kelly’s lack of character was in full view next to his boss, to where he did not bring out the best in President Trump. What’s worse is that General Kelly probably thought that he was smarter than the Commander-in-Chief which he may have been except in one skill area. General Kelly proved to have the worst political instincts of anyone in the White House to where when he interfered, he made matters worse.
Here’s the rest of the story…
On December 10, 2018, Matthew Yglesias of VOX penned the following report, “Good riddance to John Kelly (“He’s been the chief of staff America didn’t need.”)
“No person’s entire career can be summed up in a single quote. But ousted White House Chief of Staff John Kelly’s defense to the charge that the Trump administration’s child separation policy at the border was cruel deserves to be etched into his tombstone.”
“The children,” he said, “will be taken care of — put into foster care or whatever.”
“That is roughly the degree of thoughtfulness and consideration that was put into the policy. And it properly reflects Kelly’s true legacy as chief of staff.”
“The typical thing to say about Kelly is that he brought order to the White House process. He was the “grown-up in the room” who enforced discipline, but, ultimately, even Kelly, a retired Marine Corps general, could not curb President Donald Trump’s most egregious instincts.”
John Kelly, a strong-willed former military commander who is from Boston, imposed a measure of discipline on President Trump’s tumultuous presidency. http://bos.gl/9ulBc0N
Kelly will depart as White House chief of staff by end of year – The Boston Globe
President Trump says chief of staff John Kelly will leave his job at end of the year
“Kelly intervened to scuttle a potentially sensible Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) deal while mocking large numbers of DACA-eligible youth as “lazy.” He slandered Rep. Frederica Wilson (D-FL) and then for no real reason refused to apologize. He attempted to orchestrate a cover-up of White House aide Rob Porter’s alleged domestic abuse.”
“Trump is having trouble replacing Kelly. Nick Ayres, the young political operative who’d long been rumored to be next in line, apparently turned down the job. Based on Trump’s hiring track record, we can expect he’ll hire someone terrible. But the Kelly bar is exceptionally low, so America may be in for a stroke of luck.”
Trump is very poorly staffed
“We have a historical model for dealing with presidential ignorance, and it involves staffing. A strong chief of staff ensures that the right people are in front of the president, briefing him on their respective areas of expertise.”
“Kelly has been a spectacular failure in this regard. Trump has, for example, a somewhat idiosyncratic but by no means unique belief that the bipartisan consensus on free trade over the past generation has been a disaster for America. I don’t really agree with the very strong form of this critique that Trump offers, but I’m at least a little bit sympathetic to it.”
But instead of working with those people to formulate a trade policy that makes sense, Trump has an economic policy team whose main principals (Steve Mnuchin, Larry Kudlow, Kevin Hassett, and formerly Gary Cohn) think he’s wrong, and where the main players who agree with him are Peter Navarro (whose ideas are not taken seriously by anyone serious) and Wilbur Ross (who has huge financial conflicts of interest).
“As a result, Trump has embarked upon trade policies that are incomprehensible and have managed to somehow simultaneously rattle financial markets with talk of trade war while also increasing the trade deficit.”
“The chief of staff should be introducing Trump to some competent, qualified advisers who sympathize with Trump’s point of view and can help him come up with ideas that will accomplish something. (I would start with Harvard’s Dani Rodrik, the Economic Policy Institute’s Thea Lee, and the Center for Economic and Policy Research’s Dean Baker.)”
Similarly, Trump keeps complaining that Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell is too eager to raise interest rates, but Trump is not appointing people to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors who share this view. Blame accrues in the first instance to Trump for not bothering to figure this out. But Kelly’s job, for better or worse, is to help make up for some of Trump’s shortcomings, and he just hasn’t been doing it. Instead, in key areas, he’s been making things worse.”
“Coverage of Trump and Kelly’s relationship has, from the beginning, been a little bit oddly dominated by the question of Kelly’s ability (or lack thereof) to constrain Trump’s bad tweets.”
“But in the specific context of Trump, the extraordinary thing isn’t his bad tweets but the fact that he has no substantive command of any policy area. He desperately needs a capable chief of staff. Instead, he had Kelly.”
Kelly is keeping Congress dysfunctional
“In January, it briefly seemed like Democratic congressional leaders and Trump personally had a deal on immigration. The basic contours of the deal were legal status and a path to citizenship for the million or so DACA-eligible young people, who surely constitute the most sympathetic bloc of undocumented people living in the United States. They’d get this legal status in exchange for a huge $20 billion increase in border security money — including Trump’s beloved wall.”
“But as Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL) explained to Vox’s Tara Golshan at the time, Kelly kept wrecking the deal.”
“As soon as the guest leaves the office, Gen. Kelly calls in the right-wingers and they bat it down and say, ‘You can’t do it.’ We’ll never reach an agreement unless there’s a more open approach at the White House and the president is more constructive.” Durbin told Golshan.
“This president is just unable to make a promise and keep it.”
“Kelly’s idea was that Trump should hold out for sweeping changes to the law governing asylum and to the way legal immigration to the United States works. Whatever you think of these ideas on the merits, it was inconceivable that Democrats would agree to this — which Kelly surely would know if he’d ever actually listened to immigration activists instead of yelling at them.”
“The collapse of negotiations has led to a lot of anxiety and suffering among the people who could have benefited — which has, in turn, been a mild drag on the American economy. But in terms of Kelly’s negotiating objectives, he accomplished nothing. Democrats are no closer to giving in on any of these points; the DACA recipients are protected by the courts for now, at least; and Congress is still fighting about border wall funding.”
“Trump had unprecedentedly little experience in government for a president, and Kelly chose to back him up by putting himself in charge of a delicate congressional negotiation even though he also had no experience with this — and then the whole thing blew up in everyone’s face.”
America can do better than this. Even Trump can do better.
The stench should stick
“On his way out the door, Kelly seems to have a reputation (in at least some circles) as a disciplinarian who played a constructive role in the administration.”
“It’s true that, next to Trump, virtually anyone looks good. It’s also true that any chief of staff is bound to try to undercut Trump son-in-law Jared Kushner’s influence, which will almost automatically make you a sympathetic-seeming figure in comparison.”
“But the fact remains that Kelly was a true believer in some of Trump’s very worst ideas, echoed several of his very worst influences, failed completely to compensate for Trump’s most significant personal deficiencies, and intervened at key moments to make things worse.”
I was reading that Kelly isn’t liked much in his old neighborhood anymore. —- Suzanne
LikeLiked by 2 people
That’s true. There was a time when he was a hero in his neighborhood, a man who did well. There was discussion of having a statute made in his name. That attitude has changed.
There are those who say that this is a sad outcome because of his working for President Trump. I say that this association brought out his true colors. I’m saddened that he rose to the status of a 4 star general within the Marine Corp as I don’t like the idea of misogynists, Xenophobes and racists rising to the top in any military branch.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Gronda, there are several thoughts twirling around. Kelly was not perfect, but he had an unenviable task – trying to manage the unmanageable. There is an article that said Trump was surprised and had no Plan B when Ayers turned him down. I am not surprised as a good manager would have locked up the replacement before the announcement. He has only been talking about this for months. This reveals, yet again, that Trump does not do what it takes to manage.
Finally, Meadows may take the job, but he should follow his gut and decline. Anyone who takes this job will be fired. Why? The President is unmanageable, unhinged and about to be even more so on both as Mueller gets closer. So, as before, he will take out his frustrations on everyone else because he cannot be blamed for his failures. I go back to Trump’s attorney who resigned after Trump would not listen to him – he said his greatest fear is his former boss is a “f**king liar.”
LikeLiked by 2 people
Well it looks like even the GOP sycophant of President Trump, Congress Representative Meadows doesn’t want the job. This is telling as anyone can smell a future doomed man a mile away.
Gov Christie as a former prosecutor and a savvy politician would be great for the job as President Trump’s Chief of Staff if it weren’t for the fact that Jared Kushner hates him because he put his Dad in prison. The irony is that Gov. Christie would probably be the best person to negotiate his “get out of jail” card.
Gov. Christie would not have allowed that DACA / wall deal to fall through that the president made with Senators Graham and Schumer. His political instincts and skills were at a much greater level than what General Kelly has demonstrated.
Also, Governor Christie suffers from no illusions about the president without being condescending.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have absolutely no sympathy for Kelly. He ruined his own reputation by publicly displaying how alike he actually is to Individual #1.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I was never so disappointed to learn over time that the 4 star Marine General Kelly shared too many of his boss’s character flaws having to do with racism, misogyny and Xenophobia. I don’t like to see a leader in the military with these character flaws.He should be a man that the younger generation would want to emulate.
He let this country down. It can be said that he deserved to have his reputation besmirched.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Comments are closed.