aside Top General Says Puerto Rico Is The Worst Disaster That He Has Seen/ FEMA’s Fubar

The republican President Donald Trump and his apologists are not fessing up to reality. The US government has somehow fallen behind in its obligations to adequately assist our fellow Americans in Puerto Rico which was decimated by Hurricane Maria when it landed around September 20, 2017.

A week later, the president looked like he was finally taking Puerto Rico’s humanitarian crisis seriously by sending the US military to assist it and by waiving the Jones Act which allows foreign ships to deliver aid as well as US vessels.

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

Upon doing some research, I learned from an AP report that only about 5000 military soldiers were being sent when about 50,000 are needed according to a military expert, Phillip Carter, A Senior Fellow and Director of the Military, Veterans, and Society Program at the Center for a New American Security. Then I found out that the president was waiving the Jones Act for only 10 days.

The president’s need to look good is not what is needed here. What Puerto Rico requires is  a president who rolls up his sleeves to figure out how to get the job done.

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

Here’s the rest of the story…. 

On September 30, 2017, Jenny Marder of the PBS penned the following report, “After first tour of Puerto Rico, top general calls damage ‘the worst he’s ever seen.’

“Lt. Gen. Jeffrey Buchanan, the Department of Defense’s primary military liaison with FEMA, toured the damage in Puerto Rico for the first time Saturday during a helicopter ride from San Juan to Ceiba. After landing at a hangar in Ceiba with no power, internet or cellular service, Buchanan spoke with the PBS NewsHour’s Monica Villamizar.”

“Sometimes we don’t know what’s going to happen until the storm actually hits, and this is the worst I’ve ever seen,” Buchanan said.

Image result for photo of general buchanan in Puerto rico

“The trip occurred hours after President Donald Trump criticized San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulín Cruz for “poor leadership” after she spoke of devastation and “horror” on the island in the aftermath of Hurricane Maria and pleaded for help and support from the government. “We are dying here,” she said during a news conference Friday. (9/30/17)”

“Buchanan said the worst problems are on the interior of the island. “And it’s because of roads. The roads are not clear on the outside of the island, and we’re slowly working our way in. But we obviously need to get all the roads cleared so we can get supplies to people who desperately need them.”

Related image

On October 1, 2017,  Mary Anastasia O’Grady of the Wall Street Journal penned the following report,  “FEMA’s Foul-Up in Puerto Rico.” (“The emergency plan depended on generators but diesel was not delivered.”)

Excerpts:

“Hurricane Katrina taught the Federal Emergency Management Agency some harsh lessons in 2005. FEMA used what it learned to prepare and respond better when Harvey and Irma hit the U.S. mainland earlier this year. Now Maria has taken the bureaucrats back to school in Puerto Rico, and they’re not getting passing grades.”

Ahead of the Category 4 storm that hit with 155 mile-an-hour winds on Sept. 20, the FEMA team in Puerto Rico said it was ready. But a week later much of the island was still in dire need of food, water and fuel—the basics of humanitarian relief.

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

“The most immediate needs centered on the sick and elderly. About 97% of the island lost electricity in the storm. Diesel-run generators were supposed to fill the void in hospitals and dialysis centers and provide refrigeration for medicines like insulin. But the diesel fuel did not arrive, and by midweek family members began to panic. Tearful Puerto Ricans begged for help.

“FEMA will no doubt learn again from Maria. But so too should the rest of us, about the folly of relying on government to deal with a disaster even as predictable as the aftermath of a hurricane.”

 “The failures in Puerto Rico have not been due to a lack of federal attention. Rather the local FEMA team failed to execute fundamental aspects of emergency operations. Whether that’s because it was overwhelmed by the widespread devastation or because of bureaucratic incompetence can be debated. But efforts to chalk up the crisis to mainlander disregard for life are dishonest.”

Related image

“Mr. Trump’s big mistake has been his handling of the Jones Act, which mandates that shipping from the mainland to the island use only American-built-and-crewed vessels. First he said he would not suspend it as he did for Texas after Harvey and Florida after Irma. “A lot of people that work in the shipping industry . . . don’t want [it] lifted,” he said.”

“Under pressure, he finally said he would suspend the Jones Act for Puerto Rico—but only for 10 days, a meaningless gesture.”

“For more than a week the island’s ports have been piled high with containers waiting to be hitched up to cabs and their contents delivered to supermarkets, restaurants, home-building supply stores and medical centers. In other words, much of the merchandise needed in an island-wide triage is already on Puerto Rican docks.”

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

“What the island does not yet have but will have to import in the months and years ahead are billions of dollars in materials for rebuilding homes, businesses and infrastructure. This will be heavily subsidized by U.S. taxpayers, who, along with Puerto Ricans, have a right to demand globally competitive shipping rates.”

“If the president and Congress are serious about their concern for the territory, they will stand up to the shipping lobby and end once and for all what has been an injustice to Puerto Rico for nearly 100 years.”

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

“Meanwhile, the Boricua are slowly recovering from what can only be described as a giant FEMA fubar. True, an island tyrannized by labor unions some 1,200 miles from Florida with an annual per capita income of $29,000—and a bankrupt state-owned electricity monopoly—presents special challenges.”

“Yet this was common knowledge before Maria landed. So too was the high probability that cellphone service would be extremely limited in the wake of the storm. Nevertheless FEMA was caught off guard.The emergency plan centered on the use of diesel generators to replace lost electricity for hospitals and to pump drinking water. But a week after the storm 44% of the island was still without agua potable and public-health services were deteriorating.”

Related image

“Amid the chaos, Alejandro de la Campa, the local head of FEMA, tried to explain away the agency’s responsibility. “We have no control over diesel in Puerto Rico,” he said. “We have contracts with certain companies that are giving us service.”

“Right. And the fire department has no control over water.”

“The troubles went beyond diesel and turned into a supply-chain nightmare in which chaos reigned. Gasoline lines stretched miles. Merchandise at the port couldn’t be delivered due to driver shortages and the collapse of the communications infrastructure.”

“Emergency management is all about anticipating disruptions and establishing contingencies. The failure of the local FEMA office to do so is organizational negligence, not a mainland plot against our Spanish-speaking brethren.”

Image result for photos of puerto rico after hurricane maria

According to a 10/1/17 NY Times article, “Puerto Rico Is Getting a Surge of Aid, Governor Says” by Richard Fausset,  “Gov. Ricardo Rosselló told reporters that over the next 2 days, more than half a million barrels of diesel fuel and nearly a million barrels of gasoline would reach Puerto Rico. The fuel is badly needed to power emergency generators and to distribute food and other supplies across the island.”

“Mr. Rosselló said that the Defense Department had increased its footprint on Puerto Rico to 6,400 people, from roughly 4,600 two days earlier, with more coming, and that other federal agencies were also sending more staff to aid in the island’s recovery from Hurricane Maria, which smashed through the island on Sept. 20.”

LINK: How you can help hurricane victims in Puerto Rico

Related Article: One Day in the Life of Battered Puerto Rico – The New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/9/30/17

19 comments

  1. excellent post, Gronda… very informative with details and major sources. like the new acronym fubar…. (f*****- up beyond all reason…) add to SNAFU which has been around for generations and is still accurate and widely understood.

    with your permission I would like to repost this on my site. thanks for your good research skills

    • Dear Gradmama2011,

      Thanks for your gracious feedback. Not providing for diesel fuel was a major snafu. And thanks a million for your support and for this reblog.

      Hugs, Gronda

      • you do good research Gronda. My current project is researching Venezuela, I know background but things have been quiet down in SAmerica since the CIA et al are busy at work in other parts of the world.

    • Dear Roger,

      For some reason, your comment hit my funny bone. If Washington DC had been hit with a natural disaster, the biggest whiners and complainers would be those folks in the US Congress and the White House.They would make the San Juan Mayor Cruz look civil in comparison.

      Hugs, Gronda

    • @Woebegone you have a valid point. Aside from PR opportunity to make Trump look “Presidential”, the administration really isn’t doing everything in it’s power to rescue PR. To dicker around about the Jones Act is an insult to reasonable ppl. This is an emergency! This is not a drill! Ppl are in dire condition and dying!
      Our so called Prez could care less after the initial publicity has worn off. *Sigh*

  2. Gronda, the truth gets out. We were slow in addressing these issues and it shows. More is being done, but far more is needed. What is not needed is the MITWH blaming and denigrating people, especially Puerto Ricans. The reception to this man tomorrow will be interesting. Keith

    • Dear Keith,

      The president is very visual. As he tours Puerto Rico, he’ll get a better idea of what’s going on. I hope it is the 3 star Army General Buchanan giving him the tour via helicopter.. He needs to face reality and not listen to folks who are willing to gloss over what is happening.

      Hugs, Gronda

      • Gronda, I sure hope the federal government efforts are better than those of the ultimate boss on his visit. He did himself no favors by speaking of how much money the Puerto Ricans are costing them and diminished their problem as less than Katrina as they had so many more deaths.

        If he talked about cost in Texas or Florida, he would have been vilified. This people in PR lost everything as did folks in Texas and Florida. Keith

        • Dear keith,

          Why did the president have to act in such an ungracious way?. Frankly these weather catastrophes are inevitable with global warning which is a reason to push an infrastructure bill instead of a tax cut bill for the wealthy.

          It helps that both Florida and Texas have republican governors.

          Hugs, Gronda

        • Gronda, why does he do anything? Usually it traces back to his ego. He was and is being criticized for his late efforts on Puerto Rico. So he attacked and won’t let up. Keith

    • Dear Ravenhawks’ Magazine,

      I do wish the focus was on helping our fellow Americans who are in dire straights instead of all this finger pointing. Thanks a million times over for sharing this post with your reblog.

      Hugs, Gronda

    • Dear Suzanne,

      What a mess. It is heartbreaking to see peoples suffering because of these mistakes. Thanks a million for all of your support and for this reblog.

      Hugs, Gronda

  3. Dear Mz. Gronda,

    For quite a while since the weather cleared from the massive storm, I have wondered why our military was not ordered to move in a number of Chinook helicopters to the area to move emergency supplies all over the island. I suppose it would have been too easy, considering IMO about 10 Chinooks flying 12 hrs a day could have delivered supplies all over the island and bypassed the need for immediate road repairs. I don’t suppose anyone at FEMA ever gave such a simple solution to the problem.

    • Dear Crustyolemothman,

      Now that would have been a real help. Instead, It took about a week before the president sent in a general to oversea the management of providing relief to Puerto Rico.I grieve over what is happening to all those peoples who are suffering.

      Many will be moving to Orlando, Florida and maybe, then they get help.

      Hugs, Gronda

Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s