Courts Rule Against Education Secretary Betsy Devos Regarding For-Profit Schools’ Case

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

By now, “we the people” have figured out that the republican President Donald Trump and his sycophants in his administration and in the US Congress have been rarely taking concrete steps to help the average Joe worker.

Nowhere is this more true than when it comes to protecting consumers as they cater to the banking institutions that manage the student loan business and the “for profit” colleges . It looks like they have been deliberately blocking the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) from addressing consumer student loan complaints with these entities.

If the above tactics weren’t bad enough, these same GOP players were allowing the “For-Profit” colleges get away with fleecing their students with expensive loans for degrees where credits are not easily transferable to most colleges, and where the promises for great paying jobs do not always materialize, by delaying regulations created by President Obama to protect students from these entities’ predatory lending/ loan practices.

See: CBS report: For-profit colleges linked to almost all loan fraud claims 

See: President’s Administration Has Been Blocking CFPB From Addressing Student Loan Complaints/ Gronda Morin…

See: Top student loan regulator quits CFPB in protest – CNNPolitics

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

Here’s the rest of the story…

On September 14, 2018 CBS News published the following report, “Court rules against Education Secretary Betsy DeVos in for-profit college case”


“Education Secretary Betsy DeVos’ move to delay Obama-era protections for students defrauded by for-profit colleges was dealt a setback when a federal judge found her actions to be “arbitrary and capricious.”

Image result for photos of Judge Randolph Moss

“U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss ruled Wednesday (9/13/18) in a lawsuit challenging the delay that had been filed by Democratic attorneys general from 19 states and the District of Columbia and former students, finding that DeVos’ actions were unlawful.”

“The case centered on the borrower defense rule, which allowed defrauded students to have their student loans forgiven. The rule was to have taken effect on July 1, 2017. DeVos had argued those rules created “a muddled process that’s unfair to students and schools.”

“But Moss found inconsistencies in DeVos’ rationale for freezing the rule.

Image result for photos of Judge Randolph Moss

“When an agency decides to delay the effective date of a rule to save the federal government money or to alleviate confusion or a burden on regulated parties while the agency decides whether to amend or to rescind the rule, its action is ‘designed to implement … policy,'” Moss wrote in his decision .

“He said DeVos acted without conducting a rule-making process on whether to postpone the rules. Moss scheduled a hearing Friday to consider next steps.”

“Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey, who led the lawsuit, said the ruling was “a victory for every family defrauded by a predatory for-profit school.”

“Toby Merrill, a litigator at Harvard University’s Project on Predatory Student Lending, which represents defrauded students, hailed the decision as “a huge a rebuke to the department.”

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

“It’s a really big deal, it’s an incredibly important win for student borrowers and really for anyone who cares about having a government that operates under the rule of law as opposed to as a pawn of industry,” Merrill said.”

“After two decades to rapid growth, the for-profit college industry was shaken by the implosion of two major chains of schools that misled students with promises they couldn’t keep and left them with large amount of debt they couldn’t pay. The Obama administration went hard after the sector, issuing regulations meant to increase student protections and police the schools.”

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

“In trying to delay the borrower defense rule, Devos said the regulations were too broad and allowed for potential abuse on the part of students. She vowed to create a new system that would be more efficient and fair.”

“But critics dismissed the freezing of this and other regulations as an attempt by DeVos to promote industry interests. They point to the fact that DeVos has hired for-profit industry insiders to top position at her agency.”

“Rick Hess, director of education policy at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, said the Obama regulation “gives blanket forgiveness to students who may or may not have been mistreated or defrauded in any way, it puts taxpayers on the hook for potentially large payouts for people who were not misled and suffered no harm.”

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

“I think what DeVos is doing is trying to be a responsible steward who is trying to strike a healthier balance between protecting students and ensuring that taxpayers don’t get ripped off.”

“Merrill said she hopes the judge will rule that the delayed rules must now take effect. If that happens, she said, students would win some important protections: not having to sign away their right to sue the school, getting loans automatically discharged if their school was closed mid-program and if they were unable to transfer their credits to a similar program, and being eligible for forbearance when applying for loan discharges.”

Image result for cartoon about how trump is hurting student loans

“DeVos also put in place a new system of compensating defrauded students for their losses. In a break with the Obama administration’s practice of fully forgiving student loans, DeVos in December rolled out a new tiered relief system, in which students’ loans are forgiven based on their earnings.”

“That practice was frozen as part of a separate lawsuit. It was uncertain whether Wednesday’s court ruling would have any effect on the tiered relief system.”


  1. Hats off to Judge Randolph Moss for putting the citizens of this nation first for a change! I hope this is only the first of many rulings that need to be made to protect We The People instead of filling the coffers of the already-wealthy. Thanks for sharing this!


    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear Jill,

      The dark monies that are paying for the White House personnel and the GOP officials and the US Congressional lawmakers, don’t give a damn about the little guy and they are about to pay bigly for playing scrooges.

      I can’t wait to learn about how much monies they flushed down the toilet in this up coming November elections.

      Hugs, Gronda

      Liked by 1 person

      • You’re right … it isn’t about us … we are just incidentals. I suspect it will make us sick when we learn how much they threw away on a bad cause, and especially when we stop and calculate how many families could have eaten for a year on that money. 😦


        Liked by 1 person

  2. Gronda, for-profit schools mask a couple of key facts, both disturbing. The spend far more marketing than teaching. The sign folks up, get federal money and don’t care if people graduate. The other is they prey on veterans, with many veteran officers on their boards. It is not surprising that Donald Trump was involved and fined for misrepresentation. Keith

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear Keith,

      I’ve seen how they work first hand. My daughter who is Autistic but bright was much younger, she got caught up in one of these schools Kaiser and it took me 3 months to help her get out from under a contract with their school personnel.

      Their practices are predatory, in the same line as Timeshare sales.

      Hugs, Gronda


Comments are closed.