aside DOJ’s IG Horowitz Releases 18 Month Investigative Report Into FBI’s Handling Of Clinton Email Case

Image result for photos of michael horowitz

The Inspector General of the US Department of Justice (DOJ), Michael Horowitz has just formally released his 500 page report based on his 18 month long investigation surrounding the FBI’s actions regarding its management of the Hillary Clinton’s email mishandling case while she acted as US Secretary of State between 2009-2013.

The report  is highly critical of the FBI’s Director James Comey’s part in how he acted inappropriately by saying anything publicly about the Hillary Clinton’s email case when he knew she would not be criminally charged which is totally against FBI’s internal rules. But, it was determined that his actions were not politically motivated.

The final determination is that the FBI did not act with bias either for or against the Hillary Clinton’s email case. The investigation was fair.

In fact, any actions taken did damage to the Democratic Party’s Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign. Nothing was shared by the FBI agents regarding its Trump Russia probe with the public. In short, it was President Trump who benefited by the FBI’s discretion.

Image result for photos of Peter Strzok and lisa page

There is coverage of the August 2016 controversial texts between the FBI agent  Peter Strzok, a key investigator on both the Clinton email case and the Trump-Russia probe, and his girlfriend, another FBI lawyer, Lisa Page. One of the texts state, “we’ll stop” Trump from making it to the White House.”

The leaks regarding the FBI agents inappropriately sharing information about the Hillary Clinton’s email mishandling case with outsiders like Rudy Giuliani, is still ongoing.

The big surprise: The IG report did note how Director James Comey used a personal Gmail account for official government business while with the FBI, after leading the investigation into the Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server.

See: Inspector General Report on James Comey Released | Time

See:Nine Takeaways From the Inspector General’s Report on the Clinton/ Lawfare .

Image result for photos of rudy giuliani with FBI AGENTS

Here is the rest of the story…

On June 14, 2018, Devlin Barrett, Karoun Demiriian, John Warnerand Matt Zapotosky of the Washington Post penned the following report, “Inspector general blasts Comey, says others at FBI showed ‘willingness to take official action’ to hurt Trump”

Excerpts:

“The Justice Department inspector general on Thursday (6/14/18) castigated former FBI Director James B. Comey for his actions during the Hillary Clinton email investigation and found that other senior bureau officials showed a “willingness to take official action” to prevent Donald Trump from becoming president.”

“The 500-page report, a copy of which was obtained by The Washington Post, documents major missteps in one of the most politically charged cases in the FBI’s history. It also provides the most exhaustive account to date of bureau and Justice Department decision-making throughout the investigation of Clinton’s use of a private email server, particularly in the months just before she would lose the presidency to Trump.”

Image result for photos of rudy giuliani with FBI AGENTS

“Though the inspector general condemned individual FBI officials, the report fell significantly short in supporting the assertion by the president and his allies that the investigation was rigged in favor of Clinton. The inspector general found “no evidence that the conclusions by department prosecutors were affected by bias or other improper considerations.” The report acknowledged that certain emails appeared to contain classified information, but investigators determined the FBI’s conclusion that Clinton did not intend to expose classified information was legitimate.”

“The report is a blistering public rebuke of Comey. Inspector general Michael Horowitz accused Comey of insubordination, saying he flouted Justice Department practices when he decided only he had the authority and credibility to make key decisions and speak for the Justice Department.”

Image result for photos of rudy giuliani with FBI AGENTS

“Comey made a “serious error of judgment” in sending a letter to Congress on Oct. 28 announcing he was reopening the investigation of Clinton’s use of the server while secretary of state, the report found, and called it “extraordinary that Comey assessed that it was best” for him not to speak directly with either the Attorney General or the Deputy Attorney General about his decision beforehand.”

“Some senior bureau officials, the report found, exhibited a disturbing “willingness to take official action” to hurt Trump’s chances to become president.”

“Perhaps the most damaging new revelation in the report is a previously-unreported text message in which Peter Strzok, a key investigator on both the Clinton email case and the investigation of Russia and the Trump campaign, assured an FBI lawyer in August 2016 that “we’ll stop” Trump from making it to the White House.”

“[Trump’s] not ever going to become president, right? Right?!” the lawyer, Lisa Page, wrote to Strzok.

“No he won’t. We’ll stop it,” Strzok responded.

Image result for photos of Peter Strzok and lisa page

“The report aimed to define once and for all what the FBI and Justice Department did right and what was wrong in the Clinton probe, but partisans are likely to seize on different findings.”

“For Trump, the report provides chapter upon chapter of fresh ammunition for his attacks on the FBI, which he has accused of political bias in investigating whether any of his campaign associates may have conspired with Russia to influence the 2016 election.”

“To Clinton and her supporters, who have long argued that Comey’s decisions robbed her of an election victory, the report will likely be received as bitter vindication of her claims the FBI Director veered far beyond official policy in speaking publicly about her case, and reopening it in the final days before the election.”

Related image

“The messages “potentially indicated or created the appearance that investigative decisions were impacted by bias or improper considerations,” the inspector general wrote.”

Image result for photos of michael horowitz

“Even that defense, however, undercuts Comey, who had long proclaimed that his investigators “don’t give a rip about politics.”

“The president, who was briefed on the report before it was released publicly, has vigorously criticized Comey and the FBI.”

“Trump is all but certain to use the findings to renew those assaults, and potentially take aim at special counsel Robert S. Mueller III. Strzok served as Mueller’s lead agent on the Russia probe until last July, when he was removed following the discovery of the text messages.”

“David Laufman, who oversaw the Clinton probe as chief of the National Security Division’s Counterintelligence and Export Control Section, said, “The IG report demonstrates that the Justice Department lawyers who conducted the Clinton email investigation carried out their duties with the utmost rigor, professionalism, and integrity.”

Image result for photos of michael horowitz
HILLARY CLINTON

“Horowitz also concluded there was no evidence that political bias infected Comey’s thinking, even as he criticized individual steps Comey took. The report, for example, called Comey’s July 2016 public recommendation that Clinton not be charged an “extraordinary and insubordinate” move, because Comey did not even tell then-Attorney General Loretta  Lynch what he was about to do. But it added, “we found no evidence that Comey’s statement was the result of bias or an effort to influence the election.”

“Comey was not the only official to face criticism. The report chided Lynch for indecision after meeting with former president Bill Clinton on the tarmac of the Phoenix airport in the late stages of the campaign. She neither recused herself from the case to avoid the appearance of impropriety, nor did she assert herself more vigorously as Comey seized command.”

Image result for PHOTOS OF FBI MCCABE

“The report similarly raised questions about how the FBI handled the ultimate recusal of the FBI deputy director, Andrew McCabe, from that and other cases because of political donations his wife had received from a group controlled by Terry McAuliffe, a Clinton ally.”

“The report identified 5 officials with some connection to the email probe who were expressing political views, faulting them for having brought “discredit to themselves, sowed doubt about the FBI’s handling of the midyear investigation, and impacted the reputation of the FBI.” The midyear investigation refers to the Clinton email probe.”

“The messages cast a cloud over the FBI investigations to which these employees were assigned,” Horowitz alleged. “Ultimately the consequences of these actions impact not only the senders of these messages but also other who worked on these investigation and, indeed, the entire FBI.”

Related image

“The inspector general wrote that it had referred the information regarding the five individuals who exchanged politically-charged messages “to the FBI for its handling and consideration of whether the messages … violates the FBI’s Offense Code of Conduct.”

“The report took particular aim at FBI officials investigating Clinton’s email server for moving slowly after agents in the New York Field office discovered messages on the laptop of disgraced former Congressman Anthony Weiner that might be relevant to their case.”

“By no later than September 29, the inspector general alleged, the bureau had learned “virtually every fact” it would cite as justification late the next month to search Weiner’s laptop for messages of Clinton and top aide Huma Abedin.”

“The inspector general derided the bureau’s reasons for not moving more quickly — that agents were waiting for additional information from New York, that they couldn’t move without a warrant and that investigators were more focused on the Russia case — as “unpersuasive,” “illogical,” and inconsistent with their assertion that they would leave no stone unturned on Clinton.”

Related image

“The report also faulted the bureau for assigning essentially the same personnel to the Russia and Clinton teams, and singled out Strzok, suggesting his anti-Trump views might have played a role in his not acting more expeditiously on the new lead.”

“Under these circumstances, we did not have confidence that Strzok’s decision to prioritize the Russia investigation over following up on the Midyear-related investigative lead discovered on the Weiner laptop was free from bias,” the report said.”

“The report determined that several FBI investigators — including Comey — also broke bureau protocol by using “personal email accounts for official government business.”

Image result for photos of rudy giuliani with FBI AGENTS

“The inspector found 5 instances in which Comey either drafted official messages on or forwarded emails to his personal account, and at least two instances in which Strzok used his personal email for official business — including one “most troubling” instance on October 29, 2016, when he forwarded “an email about the proposed search warrant the midyear team was seeking on the Weiner laptop” from his FBI account to his personal email.”

“The discovery is ironic, given that the FBI was exploring Clinton’s own use of a personal email for work related business and whether classified information traversed her server.”

[As Justice Dept. IG moves from Clinton email to Russia and Trump, he risks becoming a political weapon]

12 comments

  1. Thanks for doing this post, my friend! I dread the next several weeks when this will be all we hear, especially from Mr. Twitter-fingers, but I am relieved that the report concludes as it does, that there was not political motivation and that the FBI acted without bias. I guess the best course is to let Trump blow off steam and the rest of us move on with the important things. Perhaps if he is largely ignored, he will shut up sooner. Though I cannot imagine the media and Trump’s fan base will do anything but play this one 24/7 for a while. Thanks again for this post … I shall re-blog it later this evening. Hugs!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear Jill,

      The president and his cronies will be making heyday of this report. The facts will be thrown out the window.

      The fact is, the only party harmed by the FBI actions prior to the 2016 November elections was Hillary Clinton.

      Even though the FBI was already knee deep into its Trump-Russia probe, it never said a peep about it to the public prior to the election.

      It was President Trump who benefited by the FBI’s missteps.

      Hugs, Gronda

      Liked by 1 person

      • No doubt they will cherry-pick and highlight only the parts they choose to, and also no doubt Trump’s followers will believe whatever he says, rather than taking time to actually read the document. I, for one, hope the brouhaha dies down soon before we all have ulcers! Hugs!!!

        Liked by 1 person

  2. “Comey made a “serious error of judgment” in sending a letter to Congress on Oct. 28 announcing he was reopening the investigation of Clinton’s use of the server while secretary of state, the report found, and called it “extraordinary that Comey assessed that it was best” for him not to speak directly with either the Attorney General or the Deputy Attorney General about his decision beforehand.”

    “Some senior bureau officials, the report found, exhibited a disturbing “willingness to take official action” to hurt Trump’s chances to become president.”

    So i still don’t understand how Comey’s actions were not considered politically motivated. If he didn’t want to affect the outcome of the election, he should know full well NOT to reopen the email investigation 10 days before the election… he couldn’t surmise the consequences of his decision? Hillary was 100% right that Comey interfered and hurt her chances of winning.

    Also how could the IG possibly determine the FBI did not act with bias either for or against the case? “The inspector general concluded that Strzok’s text, along with others disparaging Trump, “is not only indicative of a biased state of mind but, even more seriously, implies a willingness to take official action to impact the presidential candidate’s electoral prospects.”

    So clearly certain FBI agents had predisposed biases for and against Hillary or Trump. We’re human after all, and certainly entitled to an opinion, the fact is: there will be inherent biases either for or against any political opponent.

    The real question is, did Comey act in a fair and unbiased way when conducting this investigation? I’m not so sure this 18 Month Investigative Report reveals anything definitive one way or the other. This contentious election will forever be tainted with doubt. Just my 2 cents.

    Like

    • Dear 1EarthUnited,

      Both sides of the aisle will find something in the report to bolster their bias/ viewpoint.

      There is one fact that is incontrovertible, and that is, the only party harmed by the FBI actions prior to the November 2016 elections was Hillary Clinton. What I noticed is that while the FBI was knee deep already in the Trump-Russia probe, none of it was revealed before the November election.

      Mr. Comey had a Messianic complex where he bypassed the FBI’s regulations because he thought he could substitute his own judgment. This does not mean he was politically motivated. It does mean that he was flawed in his judgment and he was wrong.

      The two FBI agents who texted inappropriately have been separated from the investigation around July 2017. Their actions to date appear to have had no negative impact on President Trump but the GOP in the US Congress will be delving into this, in case to see if there is any data that could help the president’s cause.

      The IG report was designed to comment on the FBI agents’ behaviors and whether their actions affected the FBI’s final work product.

      Hugs, Gronda

      Liked by 1 person

      • The very fact that Mr. Comey bypassed FBI’s own regulations speak volumes about their level of professionalism and integrity. I believe his messianic complex did affect the FBI’s work product…. look who we have in office now! Case closed…. willingly or unwittingly, we have FBI Director Comey to thank for royally screwing America and possibly putting up with King Donnie for the next 4-8 years! What a mess. 😦

        Like

  3. Gronda, do you know what I find odd? It takes a lot of chutzpah to say the man who helped you get elected led a team that was working against you. I watched the poll numbers very closely as I was aware of the Russian meddling dating back to the end of July, 2016. I felt if HRC could have enough margin, the meddling would not impact the outcome.

    Right before Comey’s October surprise, HRC had a 6 to 8 point lead. It was sufficient that the range of outcomes were in her favor. After the Comey surprise, the median margin fell to and stayed around 1 to 3%, but the range crossed into a possible Trump victory which is what happened.

    So, to have the gall to say they were against him, especially after Obama did not act, is truly amazing. Keith

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear Keith,

      To my way of thinking, the FBI Director Comey succumbed to a lot of pressure coming from the right/ the GOP. Many had convinced themselves that she was guilty. There were FBI agents in the NYC office who were biased against HRC. This part supposedly is still under investigation by the Inspector General.

      But you are right on the money. It was Mr. Comey’s actions which cost HRC her victory while the president skated on into the White House. What’s he complaining about?

      Hugs, Gronda

      Like

  4. Gronda, you’re right about the far right spinning this report and running with it as an excuse for Trump to dismiss Mueller’s investigation! Unbelievable:

    https://thehornnews.com/james-comeys-reputation-was-ripped-to-shreds-thursday/

    “We found that it was extraordinary and insubordinate for Comey to do so, and we found none of his reasons to be a persuasive basis for deviating from well-established Department policies in a way intentionally designed to avoid supervision by department leadership over his actions,” the report says.

    Trump supporters seized on the report’s description of Comey as “insubordinate.” And they quickly focused on the report’s recounting of anti-Trump text messages from two FBI officials who worked the Clinton probe and later the Russia case, including one in which an agent says, “We’ll stop it,” with regard to a possible Trump victory.

    Like

  5. Reblogged this on Filosofa's Word and commented:
    Two days ago, the Department of Justice released the anticipated Inspector General’s report summarizing the investigation of the FBI’s handling of Hillary Clinton’s emails. I have not the stomach to delve deeply into the report, nor to watch the games Trump will play for the next several weeks, but thankfully our friend Gronda can always be counted on to do the deep digging, and so I am sharing her informative post today. The conclusions? Read Gronda’s post and find out! Thank you Gronda, for covering what I cannot, and for this highly informative post!

    Like

Comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.